Welcome to Online Guide to Divorce
Divorce Procedure Article
This is a selection made from among articles on Divorce Procedure. For a permanent link to this article, or to bookmark it for future reading, click here.
Joint Custody in Divorce
from: Erwin Seltzer
There had been a growing trend, in Ontario, in family and divorce law, over the last few years, for family courts to order joint custody of children. The hope, by some, was that the parenting skills of the parties could be improved with awards of joint custody. The recent Ontario Court of Appeal decision of Kaplanis v. Kaplanis, has tried to put this trend into perspective.
In this decision, the parties were married in 1998 and separated in January 2002. The parties had a daughter who was born in October 2001. At trial, the father requested joint custody and the mother opposed the application, stating that the parties could not communicate without screaming at each other. The trial judge granted the parties joint custody and the mother appealed the order. The appeal court set aside the order of joint custody and the mother was granted sole custody.
The Appeal Court held that, for an award of joint custody to be granted, there must be some evidence that demonstrates, that despite the parent’s own strong conflict with each other, the parties can and have cooperated and communicated appropriately with one another. In this case there was evidence to the contrary, there was no expert evidence to help the trial judge determine how a joint custody order would advance the child’s emotional and psychological needs and the child was too young to communicate her own wishes.
Approximately the same time this case was decided, the Ontario Court of Appeal also ruled on the case of Ladisa v. Ladisa, where the appeal court upheld the trial judge’s order of joint custody. In this case the trial judge had the benefit of hearing the evidence of the Children’s Lawyer who presented the children’s wishes and who recommended joint custody. It was held that the trial judge had heard evidence from third parties with respect to cooperation and appropriate communication between the parties. The trial judge also looked at the history of co-parenting during the marriage and that despite their intense conflict, the parties could and had effectively communicated with each other and placed the interests of their children ahead their own, when required.
To summarize, in Ontario joint custody cases, it would appear that the courts will now be looking more closely for evidence from third party and expert witnesses, which can demonstrate that the parties can and have cooperated and communicated appropriately and have been able to put aside their own differences and conflict, for the benefit of the children. The lack of historical cooperation and appropriate communication between the parties will greatly limit the success of a joint custody application. The assumption by some, that the granting of joint custody will improve the parenting skills of the parties, will not be a sufficient reason on it’s own to grant joint custody, in the absence of existing good cooperation and communication between the parties.
About The Author
Erwin Seltzer practices Family and Divorce Law
and Wills and Estates Law in York Region and Toronto.
Erwin can be reached at (905) 474-4333.
www.erwinseltzerdivorcefamilylaw.itgo.com
 |
 |
Divorce Procedure Specific links
Divorce Procedure News
Family Becomes Extinct, To Be Replaced with Feminism and Gender Equality
The Russians gradually lose interest in marriage and family. Recent opinion polls conducted in the Krasnoyarsk region showed that 72 of each 100 marriages end with divorce. Demographers say that family as a social unit became irrational because of the financial crisis.
Read more...Sandra Continues Reign As Most Perfect Person, Has Perfect Baby And Perfect Friends
Sandra Bullock made a rare post-divorce appearance on The Today Show this morning, but she wasn’t talking about Jesse James. She was discussing the other man in her life, baby Louis, who she calls her “crown prince” and her “Cajun cookie.” Bullock discussed her adoption procedure and, when asked how she kept it a secret for so long, attributed it to having amazing friends. “It takes good people ...
Read more...Broomfield Enterprise upcoming events -- Sept. 2
Upcoming events in and around Broomfield
Read more...WATCH: Hurricane Earl Threatens East Coast
The director of the National Hurricane Center Bill Read talks about Earl's path. National Hurricane Center - Meteorology - Hurricanes - Earth Sciences - Atmospheric Sciences
Read more...Christina Holder: Zambia's Constitutional Review Process Has Thwarted Meaningful Public Participation
"A costly spectacle." "A circus." "A charade." This is how some detractors in the Zambian media have described the NCC, the body charged with the task of rewriting the Zambian Constitution.
Read more...